|
There were 11 submissions to this contest. All
submissions including videos and additional images can be downloaded here.
(~ 550 MB).
For each paper, three
reviews have been made by visualization experts. For the best papers (upper
80%), two additional reviews have been done by neurosurgical domain experts (see
committee for details).
The winning submission and three
honorable-mention submissions will be announced at IEEE Vis 2010.
Congratulations to the winner and the three honorable-mention
submissions:
| Winner |
Pre-Operative Planning of Brain
Tumor Resections
Stefan Diepenbrock, Jörg-Stefan Praßni, Florian Lindemann, Hans-Werner Bothe, Timo Ropinski |
| |
|
| Honorable mention |
An Exploration and Planning Tool for
Neurosurgical Interventions
Diana Röttger, Sandy Engelhardt, Christopher Denter, Burkhard
Güssefeld, Annette Hausdörfer, Gerrit Lochmann, Dominik Ospelt,
Janine Paschke, QiAn Tao, Stefan Müller |
| |
|
| Honorable mention |
Neurosurgical Intervention
Planning with VolV
Silvia Born, Daniela Wellein, Peter Rhone,
Matthias Pfeifle, Jan Friedrich, Dirk Bartz |
| |
|
| Honorable mention |
A Fiber Navigator for Neurosurgical Planning
(NeuroPlanningNavigator)
Olivier Vaillancourt, Gabriel Girard, Arnaud Bore, Maxime Descoteaux |
Further submissions in alphabetical order of submission title:
Anonymous,
Anonymous |
| |
Camera Control for Brain-Tumor Visualization
Peter Stein, Hina Shah |
| |
Distance Functions in Multimodal Volume Rendering
Roland Fraedrich, Jens Schneider, Thomas Fogal, Philipp
Landgraf, Mirco Richter, Rüdiger Westermann, Dorit Merhof,
Jens Krüger |
| |
Multivariate Beam Ray Obstacle Visualization for Brain
Tumor Resection
Bernhard Kainz, Rsotislav Khlebnikov,
Alexander Bornik, Dieter Schmalstieg |
| |
Quantitative Visualization of Access Paths for
Preoperative Planning in Neurosurgery
Lin Zheng, Yubo
Zhang, Kwan-Liu Ma |
| |
Rendering data using three different methods
Chung Shang Lin, Ming Da Chen, Wen Jay Shen |
| |
The 3D Mousing Interaction Technique
Douglas
Coimbra de Andrade, Edmundo Mizutani |
Reviews of neurosurgical
domain experts. The ranking does NOT correspond to the submission
number! (9 = highest score, 0 = lowest score)
| |
Clarity (2,5%) |
Technical Soundness (2,5%) |
Multi-modality (5%) |
Quality of Vis (5%) |
Quality of Interaction (5%) |
Clinical value (20%) |
Uncertainty (10%) |
Overall recommendation (50%) |
Weighted avg score |
| 1 |
8 / 8 |
6 / 8 |
8 / 7 |
8 / 7 |
8 / 7 |
9 / 7 |
8 / 8 |
8 / 8 |
7,80 |
| 2 |
8 / 8 |
8 / 7 |
8 / 7 |
9 / 7 |
9 / 7 |
9 / 7 |
0 / 3 |
8 / 7 |
7,06 |
| 3 |
8 / 7 |
8 / 7 |
8 / 6 |
8 / 5 |
8 / 5 |
9 / 5 |
9 / 2 |
8 / 5 |
6,48 |
| 4 |
6 / 7 |
7 / 7 |
8 / 4 |
8 / 7 |
7 / 5 |
7 / 7 |
7 / 3 |
7 / 5 |
6,24 |
| 5 |
8 / 5 |
6 / 7 |
8 / 6 |
7 / 6 |
7 / 0 |
8 / 6 |
7 / 9 |
8 / 5 |
5,93 |
| 6 |
9 / 7 |
9 / 8 |
9 / 7 |
9 / 3 |
9 / 4 |
9 / 2 |
0 / 1 |
8,5 / 4 |
5,84 |
| 7 |
6 / 8 |
6 / 8 |
5 / 8 |
5 / 6 |
4 / 7 |
4 / 7 |
1 / 4 |
5 / 7 |
5,58 |
| 8 (*) |
0 / ? |
0 / ? |
5 / ? |
5 / ? |
0 / ? |
7 / ? |
0 / ? |
7 / ? |
4,75 |
| 9 |
4 / 7 |
6 / 7 |
4 / 7 |
4 / 5 |
7 / 7 |
4 / 4 |
2 / 4 |
2 / 6 |
4,48 |
| 10 (**) |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
| 11 ( **) |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
- / - |
(*) second review is still missing
(**) only the upper 80% of papers reviewed by vis experts have also
been reviewed by neurosurgical domain experts
Reviews of visualization experts. The ranking does NOT
correspond to the submission number! (9 = highest score, 0 = lowest score)
| |
Clarity (2,5%) |
Technical Soundness (2,5%) |
Multi-modality (5%) |
Quality of Vis (20%) |
Quality of Interaction (10%) |
Uncertainty (10%) |
Overall recommendation (50%) |
Weighted avg score |
| 1 |
6 / 9 / 9 |
6 / 9 / 8 |
6 / 8 / 9 |
6 / 6 / 7 |
6 / 8 / 7 |
5 / 8 / 8 |
5,5 / 8 / 8 |
7,09 |
| 2 |
8 / 9 / 7 |
7 / 9 / 6 |
7 / 7 / 8 |
7 / 8 / 7 |
7 / 6 / 7 |
3 / 5 / 7 |
6 / 7 / 8 |
6,88 |
| 3 |
8 / 8 / 8 |
7 / 8 / 8 |
7 / 8 / 8 |
7 / 7 / 7 |
6 / 7 / 7 |
2 / 3 / 5 |
7 / 6 / 8 |
6,71 |
| 4 |
8 / 9 / 9 |
5 / 9 / 9 |
5 / 8 / 7 |
7 / 8 / 8 |
5 / 7 / 6 |
1 / 6 / 0 |
5 / 8 / 8 |
6,61 |
| 5 |
8 / 6 / 3 |
7 / 8 / 2 |
7 / 8 / 8 |
6 / 7 / 5 |
6 / 7 / 5 |
6 / 3 / 7 |
5,5 / 6 / 5 |
5,75 |
| 6 |
7 / 8 / 7 |
7 / 8 / 5 |
5 / 8 / 6 |
6 / 5 / 5 |
5 / 7 / 5 |
6 / 6 / 5 |
6 / 7 / 5 |
5,73 |
| 7 |
9 / 9 / 8 |
8 / 8 / 6 |
7 / 8 / 6 |
4 / 8 / 6 |
6 / 3 / 6 |
1 / 0 / 0 |
7 / 6 / 6 |
5,65 |
| 8 |
6 / 9 / 6 |
6 / 7 / 7 |
4 / 5 / 8 |
3 / 5 / 3 |
6 / 5 / 6 |
0 / 0 / 0 |
3 / 5 / 6 |
4,23 |
| 9 |
0 / 0 / 0 |
0 / 0 / 0 |
3 / 7 / 8 |
3 / 7 / 6 |
3 / 5 / 0 |
0 / 0 / 0 |
2 / 5 / 5 |
3,63 |
| 10 |
1 / 6 / 4 |
2 / 3 / 4 |
2 / 2 / 2 |
1 / 3 / 2 |
1 / 4 / 3 |
0 / 0 / 0 |
1 / 2 / 3 |
1,93 |
| 11 |
2 / 5 / 2 |
2 / 1 / 0 |
1 / 0 / 0 |
1 / 1 / 0 |
1 / 0 / 0 |
0 / 0 / 0 |
1 / 1 / 0 |
0,62 |
|
